← All writing

Same Kids, Different Doors

Child welfare, juvenile justice, homelessness and exploitation

Jack Martin | Trusted Transformation Solutions

A Tuesday night in a group home

Picture a 15-year-old in a group home on a Tuesday night. A phone call with her mother goes badly. She slams a door hard enough to crack the frame. A staff member covering a double shift calls the police.

In most family homes, that night ends with a hard conversation and a repair bill. In a group home, it can end with a charge.

Now she has two case numbers. A caseworker and a probation officer. Two court dates, two case plans and two sets of rules that do not always agree. A few years later she turns 18, and both systems close their files within months of each other.

She still needs somewhere to sleep.

That is not four separate problems. It is the same young person walking through four doors: child welfare, juvenile justice, homelessness and, too often, exploitation. We built a separate system behind each door. The young person does not experience them separately.

I came up through the juvenile court and child welfare system myself, and I spent more than 30 years in law enforcement. I have seen this from both sides of the desk. Most of the people inside these systems are doing their jobs well. The handoffs between the systems are where kids fall.

The overlap is not small

How many youth touch both child welfare and juvenile justice depends on how you count and where you look. The estimates vary a lot. That is worth saying out loud, because numbers in this field get repeated long after anyone has checked them.

Here is what the better studies show. When researchers linked records in three large jurisdictions, they found that among youth adjudicated in juvenile court, 44.8% in Cook County, 68.5% in Cuyahoga County and 70.3% in New York City were dual system youth (Herz et al., 2019). The National Institute of Justice, summarizing that work, concluded that half or more of the youth entering juvenile justice may have child welfare histories (Kelley & Haskins, n.d.). Looking from the other direction, a Connecticut study found that 16.6% of youth involved with the state child welfare agency later had contact with juvenile justice (UConn Center for Applied Research in Human Development, 2015).

Who crosses over is not random. Black youth and girls are more likely to become dual system youth, and youth with long child welfare histories and multiple out-of-home placements tend to go deeper into juvenile justice (Kelley & Haskins, n.d.). LGBTQ youth are overrepresented too. In a random sample of Los Angeles County foster youth, 19% identified as LGBTQ, roughly 1.5 to 2 times the rate outside foster care, and they had more placements on average and were more likely to be living in group homes (Wilson et al., 2014).

Care can become a pathway

Nobody designs a foster placement to produce a delinquency petition. The research points to a few places where it happens anyway.

Where a kid lives matters. In Los Angeles County, youth with at least one group home placement were about two and a half times more likely to be arrested than similar youth in foster homes, and most of those first arrests happened while the youth was under group home supervision (Ryan et al., 2008). That is the Tuesday night above, in data. A shift supervisor with no other option calls the police. A parent usually does not.

How often a kid moves matters. In Illinois, maltreated children had delinquency rates about 47% higher than other children. For boys, instability was the driver: the odds of delinquency were about 1.5 times higher with three placements and 2.1 times higher with four or more (Ryan & Testa, 2005).

School moves matter. Between 56% and 75% of youth change schools when they first enter care, and about a third of 17- and 18-year-olds in care have changed schools five or more times (National Working Group on Foster Care and Education, 2014). Every move resets credits, friendships and the adults who know the kid well enough to notice when something is off.

A fair caution: these are associations. They do not prove that placement alone causes delinquency, and kids who move a lot often have more going on to begin with. That does not let us off the hook. It does mean the fix is not fewer moves on a spreadsheet. It is fewer reasons to move.

Leaving care is not landing

The day a case closes is a milestone for the system. For the young person, it is often the start of the hardest stretch.

In the Midwest Study, which followed more than 700 young people aging out of care in Illinois, Iowa and Wisconsin, between 31% and 46% had been homeless at least once by age 26 (Dworsky, Napolitano & Courtney, 2013). In Washington State, about one in four young people who aged out experienced homelessness within the first year. Youth with juvenile justice involvement, disrupted adoptions or multiple placements, especially in congregate care, were more likely to become homeless. Youth who had ever been placed with a relative were less likely (Shah et al., 2017).

Look at it from the shelter side and the picture holds. Chapin Hall’s Voices of Youth Count found that one in ten young adults ages 18 to 25, and one in thirty adolescents ages 13 to 17, experience some form of homelessness over a year (Morton, Dworsky & Samuels, 2017). Between one-quarter and one-third of the young people experiencing homelessness had been in foster care, and not only those who aged out. Some had been reunified or adopted (Dworsky et al., 2019).

Homelessness then feeds justice contact. The Coalition for Juvenile Justice’s Principles for Change, developed with the National Network for Youth and the National League of Cities, cites a federally funded study of runaway and homeless youth in 11 cities: nearly 78% had at least one interaction with police, almost 62% had been arrested, and almost 44% had been in jail, prison or juvenile detention (Coalition for Juvenile Justice, 2017). Curfews, trespass and loitering rules, and truancy for a kid with no stable address to leave from in the morning all open the next door.

Exploitation follows instability

The young people most at risk of being sold for sex are, very often, the young people our systems already know.

In a study of homeless youth across 13 cities, led by Covenant House with Loyola University New Orleans and the University of Pennsylvania, about 19% had experienced some form of human trafficking and 15% had been trafficked for sex, including 21.4% of young women. LGBTQ youth were 19% of the sample but 34% of the sex trafficking victims (Covenant House et al., 2017; Murphy, 2017). The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children reported that of the more than 11,800 endangered runaways reported to it in 2015, one in five were likely victims of child sex trafficking, and 74% of those were in the care of social services when they went missing (NCMEC, n.d.).

Much of this starts as survival. Urban Institute researchers interviewed 283 LGBTQ young people in New York City who traded sex to meet basic needs like food and shelter, and documented how often they were arrested and caught between the justice and child welfare systems instead of helped by them (Dank et al., 2015). For girls, the pattern has a name: the sexual abuse to prison pipeline, where girls’ reactions to abuse, including running away and being trafficked, get treated as offenses (Saar et al., 2015).

Federal law already expects child welfare to act on this. The Preventing Sex Trafficking and Strengthening Families Act of 2014 requires state child welfare agencies to identify, document and serve children in their care who are sex trafficking victims or at risk, to report them to law enforcement, and to have plans to locate youth who run from care (P.L. 113-183). In most places the question is no longer whether there is a policy.

It is whether the policy reaches the night shift.

What the evidence actually supports

This is where honesty matters most, because this is the section that drives funding decisions. Some of what gets cited in this field claims more than the research shows. Here is what holds up.

Cross-system practice models. Georgetown’s Crossover Youth Practice Model has been implemented in more than 125 jurisdictions in 23 states since 2010 (Georgetown Center for Youth Justice, n.d.). Its process gains are real: earlier identification, better information sharing and coordinated case supervision (OJJDP, 2019). The outcome evidence is thinner. One comparison-group evaluation found the model improved how cases were handled but did not significantly reduce recidivism (Wright, Spohn & Campagna, 2020). In Idaho, youth who crossed over after the model was in place were more likely to have their juvenile cases dismissed or diverted (Idaho Statistical Analysis Center, 2021). Worth doing. Not a magic number.

Supportive housing for families. The Corporation for Supportive Housing’s Keeping Families Together pilot in New York City housed 29 homeless families with child welfare histories. About 90% stayed housed, 61% of open child welfare cases closed during the pilot, and every child who was eligible to return home did (CSH, 2011). It was a small pilot without a control group. Promising, and it should be described at its actual size.

Family-based treatment. Multisystemic Therapy has some of the strongest long-term evidence in juvenile justice. In a randomized trial with serious and violent juvenile offenders followed into midlife, 34.8% of MST participants committed a felony, compared with 54.8% of those who received individual therapy (Sawyer & Borduin, 2011). That trial was not specific to crossover youth, so we should not present it as if it were.

Cash. California is testing guaranteed income for young people aging out of extended foster care, with county pilots paying $1,000 to $1,200 a month. Early Chapin Hall findings show more stable housing, less food insecurity and better mental health while the payments lasted, with some gains slipping once they ended (Chapin Hall, 2026). A randomized statewide evaluation by the Urban Institute is under way. We should watch it closely and not claim results it has not produced yet.

Relatives. One of the clearest protective factors in the housing research is placement with a relative at some point in care (Shah et al., 2017). That is a permanency finding as much as a housing finding.

What we should do

None of this requires inventing a new system. It requires the ones we have to stop handing kids off and walking away.

Find crossover youth at the front door. Every detention intake and every juvenile court filing should ask one question: does this young person have an open or past child welfare case? If the answer is yes, both systems should be at the table before the next decision, not after it.

Stop charging kids for what we would handle at home. Group homes and shelters need written expectations for when staff call police, and a supervisor who reviews every call. The 2014 federal law already requires states to let caregivers use a “reasonable and prudent parent” standard for normal childhood activities. The same thinking belongs on a normal adolescent bad night.

Protect placement and school stability. Fewer moves, and when a move happens, keep the school. Count school changes as an outcome, not a footnote.

Plan the landing, not just the exit. Use what is already on the books: extended foster care to 21, Chafee services to 23 in states that extend care, and HUD’s Foster Youth to Independence vouchers, which provide up to 36 months of rental assistance for youth 18 to 24, with up to 24 more months for those who qualify. Pair every voucher with a person. A key without a contact name is a short-term fix.

Treat exploited youth as victims. Screen at every entry point, as federal law already requires of child welfare, and adopt safe harbor protections so a trafficked child is never booked as the offender.

Build it with the people who lived it. Pay young people and alumni with system experience for their time on planning and oversight bodies, and give youth advisory boards real decisions, not just a seat. Track racial disparities at every decision point (referral, detention, charging, placement moves) so we can see where the gaps open.

Fund the handoff. Braid child welfare, juvenile justice, housing and Medicaid dollars around the young person, not around the agency.

One thing to do this week

Pull the last ten youth admitted to detention in your jurisdiction. Check how many had a child welfare case, open or closed. Then ask whether anyone from that case knew they were in detention.

If the answer surprises you, you have found your first handoff to fix.

A file can close on a Friday. The kid still needs somewhere to be on Monday.

References

Chapin Hall. (2026). Evaluating guaranteed income pilots in San Francisco and Alameda County [Research brief series]. Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago.

Coalition for Juvenile Justice. (2017). Addressing the intersections of juvenile justice involvement and youth homelessness: Principles for change. With the National Network for Youth and the National League of Cities Institute for Youth, Education, and Families.

Corporation for Supportive Housing. (2011). Keeping Families Together: Pilot evaluation results (evaluation by Metis Associates). CSH.

Covenant House International, Loyola University New Orleans Modern Slavery Research Project, & University of Pennsylvania Field Center for Children’s Policy, Practice & Research. (2017). Labor and sex trafficking among homeless youth [Multi-city study findings].

Dank, M., Yu, L., Yahner, J., Pelletier, E., Mora, M., & Conner, B. (2015). Locked in: Interactions with the criminal justice and child welfare systems for LGBTQ youth, YMSM, and YWSW who engage in survival sex. Urban Institute.

Dworsky, A., Gitlow, E., Horwitz, B., & Samuels, G. M. (2019). Missed opportunities: Pathways from foster care to youth homelessness in America. Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago.

Dworsky, A., Napolitano, L., & Courtney, M. (2013). Homelessness during the transition from foster care to adulthood. American Journal of Public Health, 103(S2), S318–S323.

Georgetown University Center for Youth Justice. (n.d.). Crossover Youth Practice Model. https://cyj.georgetown.edu/our-work/crossover-youth-practice-model/

Herz, D. C., Dierkhising, C. B., Raithel, J., Schretzman, M., Guiltinan, S., Goerge, R. M., Cho, Y., Coulton, C., & Abbott, S. (2019). Dual system youth and their pathways: A comparison of incidence, characteristics and system experiences using linked administrative data. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 48, 2432–2450.

Idaho Statistical Analysis Center. (2021). Crossover youth in Eastern Idaho: Results from the District 6 Crossover Youth Practice Model pilot project. Idaho State Police.

Kelley, B. T., & Haskins, P. A. (n.d.). Dual system youth: At the intersection of child maltreatment and delinquency. National Institute of Justice.

Morton, M. H., Dworsky, A., & Samuels, G. M. (2017). Missed opportunities: Youth homelessness in America. National estimates. Chapin Hall at the University of Chicago.

Murphy, L. T. (2017). Labor and sex trafficking among homeless youth: A ten-city study. Loyola University New Orleans, Modern Slavery Research Project.

National Center for Missing & Exploited Children. (n.d.). Key facts [2015 data]. https://www.missingkids.org/KeyFacts

National Working Group on Foster Care and Education. (2014). Fostering success in education: National factsheet on the educational outcomes of children in foster care. Legal Center for Foster Care and Education.

Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. (2019, March/April). Dual system youth research summary. OJJDP News @ a Glance.

Preventing Sex Trafficking and Strengthening Families Act, Pub. L. No. 113-183 (2014).

Ryan, J. P., Marshall, J. M., Herz, D., & Hernandez, P. M. (2008). Juvenile delinquency in child welfare: Investigating group home effects. Children and Youth Services Review, 30(9), 1088–1099.

Ryan, J. P., & Testa, M. F. (2005). Child maltreatment and juvenile delinquency: Investigating the role of placement and placement instability. Children and Youth Services Review, 27(3), 227–249.

Saar, M. S., Epstein, R., Rosenthal, L., & Vafa, Y. (2015). The sexual abuse to prison pipeline: The girls’ story. Human Rights Project for Girls, Georgetown Law Center on Poverty and Inequality, & Ms. Foundation for Women.

Sawyer, A. M., & Borduin, C. M. (2011). Effects of multisystemic therapy through midlife: A 21.9-year follow-up to a randomized clinical trial with serious and violent juvenile offenders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 79(5), 643–652.

Shah, M. F., Liu, Q., Eddy, J. M., Barkan, S., Marshall, D., Mancuso, D., Lucenko, B., & Huber, A. (2017). Predicting homelessness among emerging adults aging out of foster care. American Journal of Community Psychology, 60(1–2).

UConn Center for Applied Research in Human Development. (2015). Research brief: Connecticut’s crossover youth. University of Connecticut.

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. (n.d.). Foster Youth to Independence (FYI) initiative. HUD.

Wilson, B. D. M., Cooper, K., Kastanis, A., & Nezhad, S. (2014). Sexual and gender minority youth in foster care: Assessing disproportionality and disparities in Los Angeles. The Williams Institute, UCLA School of Law.

Wright, E. M., Spohn, R., & Campagna, M. (2020). Responding to crossover youth: A look beyond recidivism outcomes. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 18(4), 381–394.